Two Marian subjects can look similar at first glance. An image of the Immaculate Heart offers Mary’s heart as a focus for devotion. Paintings of the Immaculate Conception depict Mary and the Catholic belief that she was preserved from original sin from the first moment of her own conception.
This guide starts with Leopold Kupelwieser’s Heart of Mary, then compares nine Immaculate Conception paintings. Look for the crescent, stars and clouds, and notice how each artist gives those signs a different place in the composition.
1. The Heart of Mary — Leopold Kupelwieser

Kupelwieser’s work provides a historical point of comparison for the heart imagery seen in the companion guide. Locate the emblem first and then look at how the figure presents it. Its visibility distinguishes the subject from the Immaculate Conceptions below.
2. The Immaculate Conception — Diego Velázquez

Velázquez places Mary above the crescent, with the signs of the celestial vision arranged around her. The National Gallery pairs the painting with Saint John on the Island of Patmos. Seen together, they help explain the link with the imagery of Revelation.
3. The Immaculate Conception — Bartolomé Esteban Murillo

Murillo often lets the position of Mary’s hands and the surrounding movement of fabric guide attention toward the face. Compare the feeling of upward movement here with the greater stillness in Velázquez.
4. The Immaculate Conception — Francisco de Zurbarán

Zurbarán’s approach gives the solitary figure a strong presence. Notice how the setting and the areas around Mary carry part of the meaning. Comparing this work with Murillo shows how much can vary within the same subject.
5. Allegory of the Immaculate Conception — Giovanni Battista Tiepolo

Tiepolo’s title identifies the work as an allegory. Follow the movement around the main figure before considering the smaller motifs. The grouping lets the subject unfold across more than one level of the composition.
6. The Immaculate Conception — Anton Raphael Mengs

Mengs offers a measured counterpart to Tiepolo. Look for the order of the central silhouette and the spaces left around it. The distinct outlines can make the image feel still even where the composition directs attention upward.
7. The Immaculate Virgin with Fernando de Mata — Juan de Roelas

Roelas gives the Jesuit Fernando de Mata a place in the picture. The Berlin catalogue connects the painting to seventeenth-century debates around the devotion. Look from the donor toward Mary to see how the picture gives the act of veneration a place.
8. The Immaculate Conception — Carlo Maratta

In Maratta’s treatment, follow the main figure before looking at the secondary shapes. The comparison with Roelas shows how differently painters can organize the space around Mary.
9. The Immaculate Conception — Antonio Ciseri

Ciseri brings the subject into a later tradition of painting. Compare the modeling of face and drapery with the seventeenth-century examples. Differences in handling change how close Mary seems to the viewer.
10. The Immaculate Conception with Two Donors — Juan de Valdés Leal

Valdés Leal includes two donors in the composition. Notice how their positions set up a relationship with the central figure. Compare it with Roelas, where one named donor gives the viewer a distinct place to begin.
How to distinguish the two subjects
Start with the heart itself. If Mary presents it as the focus, begin with the devotion to her Immaculate Heart. In the Immaculate Conception tradition, a crescent beneath Mary and a sky filled with clouds or angels help organize the image. Check the work’s title and context when attributes overlap.
What changes when donors appear?
Compare the donor in Roelas with the two donors in Valdés Leal. Each gives the painting a human point of entry. Following their gaze or posture helps explain how the artist relates earthly devotion to the figure of Mary.